Re: Summertime, sdf user atyh 07/21/22
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SDF user  atyh recently posted about  living on their property  in the
summer.[1] I absolutely  love the visual that was painted,  as well as
the details on the scythe and the bath.

There was one thing that got me a little, and that was the description
of their interaction with the county where they live in the PNW:

"There are  of course the continual  struggles with the county  in the
background, as they  are quite frustrated that we live  so simply, and
entirely  off grid.  My cynicism  toward modern  government has  grown
significantly in the  last two years as I have  learned more about how
they operate.  It is  my current belief  that 20% of  what they  do is
necessary, and  the other 80%  is all activity designed  to perpetuate
and  grow their  bureaucracy  through extortionary  policy making.  But
Pareto could  have told us  this long  ago. Currently, unless  we show
regular  'progress'  toward  a  conventional house  with  all  of  the
environmental damage which comes with  that, they threaten to chase us
off  our own  land. Strange  that they  think this  is right.  Forcing
people off of their own rural land  for not living in a structure with
a concrete foundation."

I  lived in  the PNW--outside  of  Portland, OR,  in rural  Washington
County, to be exact--for about 20  years. My mom still lives there, on
60acres of land that she basically  cannot use or divide. She can live
there, or  sell it to the  vineyards that are slowly  buying the entire
countryside.

atyh, the  reason the county is  "quite frustrated that [you]  live so
simply, and  entirely off grid"  is directly  tied to two  things: the
way  counties collect  revenue,  and the  way  local government  views
individual liberty.  In Oregon where  there is no sales  tax, property
tax  is the  sole  source  of revenue.  To  be  fair, Oregon's  median
property tax  rate is fairly  average. However, that average  tax must
supply the governments needs and wants--and it is based on land value.
Land  value  changes  dramatically  when a  structure  is  permanently
affixed to the real estate.

You can  see where this is  going: county government wants  you to use
your land  in ways  that increase the  real, taxable  value. Off-grid,
temporary, and non-standard structures  and lifestyles do not increase
land value.

In  my  mom's  county,  they  regulate these  valueless  uses  out  of
existence.  What you're  doing would  be practically  criminal in  her
county's  eyes.  And  that  is  where  the  government's  approach  to
personal liberty comes into the  equation. There are places where such
regulation will and does get tolerated, and places where it just won't
happen. And, I'm sad to say, it's politics.

Land use was one  of several reasons I left the PNW.  I would even say
it was one of the biggest reasons.

Most  recently, we  relocated to  Missouri. Had  never even  been here
before we  moved. There were a  number of micro reasons,  but no macro
ones.  And I  hadn't even  fully  considered land  use. However,  upon
meeting different people and learning  more, I came to understand that
Callaway County  in particular has  almost zero land  use restrictions
(on county  land; cities have  their own  rules.) The only  thing they
regulate  is waste  disposal (you'll  need a  county approved  system,
either septic  or lagoon or some  other exception, to build  a house.)
There are zero inspections apart from that (seriously, none. You could
build an  entire house from foundation  to roof, and the  county won't
inspect any aspect of it. This means  you have to be very careful when
buying a  home outside  city limits.) You  could literally  build your
house out of straw bales[2], powered  by rain water collection and 12v
solar, and no one would care. I  imagine that if you're not building a
deed-attached home, you could just live  on your land here without any
government contact at all*.

Another thing that  they get you with  in the PNW is  occupancy. In my
mom's county, the only way to get  two houses on her 60acres is to get
special  permission for  farm  help or  an exemption  for  an aged  or
disabled family member. Contrast that  with Callaway County, where you
could slap  half a  dozen houses  on your land,  all sharing  the same
driveway  (I know  people with  almost  that many  houses, for  family
members, on one  piece of property.) And again, no  one will be coming
'round to inspect any of it.

My point  isn't to claim that  Callaway County, Missouri is  somehow a
Utopia. It isn't (though, it is  green and beautiful!) Nor am I saying
that you ought to  sell your land in the PNW and  move to Missouri. My
whole point is  to throw a light  on land use laws, and  how they vary
from county to  county, and state to state. People  who are interested
in off grid or alternative  living should start first by understanding
land use laws, and understanding that they do vary wildly.

* As long  as you have no children. Most  governments classify neglect
in  terms of  basic living  conditions including  electricity, running
water, etc.

[1] gopher://sdf.org:70/0/users/atyh/phlog/summertime.txt
[2] https://strawbale.com/