[HN Gopher] Robbie Robertson has died
___________________________________________________________________
 
Robbie Robertson has died
 
Author : karaokeyoga
Score  : 92 points
Date   : 2023-08-09 20:52 UTC (1 days ago)
 
web link (www.nytimes.com)
w3m dump (www.nytimes.com)
 
| 2OEH8eoCRo0 wrote:
| The Last Waltz is fantastic. Rest in peace.
 
  | jlevy wrote:
  | +1 -- nothing better.
 
| eltondegeneres wrote:
| > his biological father was a Jewish professional gambler named
| Alexander David Klegerman, who had been killed in a hit-and-run
| accident before she met James Robertson
| 
| Killing someone and fleeing the scene isn't something that
| happens by accident.
 
  | andrewl wrote:
  | You can hit somebody accidentally, and then run from the
  | accident intentionally.
 
| munk-a wrote:
| He was an extremely influential artist and his time with The Band
| was legendary of course - but his solo work is also certainly
| worth investigating especially "Contact from the Underworld of
| Redboy".
 
  | ChristianGeek wrote:
  | "Somewhere Down the Crazy River" from his first, self-titled
  | album is sublime.
 
| brianzelip wrote:
| RIP
| 
| 'Up on Cripple Creek' was my first explicit introduction to them.
| After buying their 1969 self titled album on a whim, my jaw
| dropped from hearing the original sample from GangStarr's "Beyond
| Comprehension" off their 1990 'Step in the Arena'. That isolated
| drum roll and guitar lick is so mystical. I could listen to those
| brief 3 seconds on loop for hours.
 
| jlevy wrote:
| Great quote: Speaking of the Band in the 2020 documentary "Once
| Were Brothers," Bruce Springsteen said, "It's like you've never
| heard them before and like they'd always been there."
 
  | NaOH wrote:
  | Similarly, this was a great line from the LA Times obituary for
  | Robertson:
  | 
  | >As the Band's chief songwriter and grand conceptualist,
  | Robertson turned old American folklore into modern myths, a
  | knack that gave a timeless quality to such songs as "The
  | Weight" and "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down"; it was as if
  | he had unearthed the songs, not written them.
 
| SubGenius wrote:
| Sad.
| 
| If I had to choose the greatest song ever written, I would not
| hesitate to go with The Weight. The version [0] from The Waltz is
| especially brilliant.
| 
| [0] - https://youtu.be/q-w9OclUnns
 
  | oDot wrote:
  | No better clapping than Mavis'
 
    | tnecniv wrote:
    | She also does an awesome version of For What It's Worth
 
  | karaokeyoga wrote:
  | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCSzL5-SPHM (better resolution)
 
    | HighChaparral wrote:
    | I just love this. Scorsese's camera moves - the way he swoops
    | in behind Mavis and then slowly comes back around her as she
    | starts to soar. The way he lights up Danko for the start of
    | his solo bit. It's just a beautifully put together document
    | of a great performance. It was shot separately on a
    | soundstage, making it essentially an early music video, and a
    | great one at that. That Robertson and Scorsese were still
    | working together right to the end just makes it all the more
    | poignant and wondrous.
 
  | klausnrooster wrote:
  | Another nice version, although the one you linked is my
  | favorite: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ph1GU1qQ1zQ
 
    | SubGenius wrote:
    | That's a pretty dope version as well. I do like Marcus King a
    | lot.
    | 
    | Also, nice username. ;)
 
  | EFreethought wrote:
  | His first solo album is one of my favorites.
 
    | zeruch wrote:
    | His solo debut and Storyville are a perfect one-two punch.
 
  | AlbertCory wrote:
  | in _Once Were Brothers_ they said when they played it for Dylan
  | he looked at Robbie, disbelieving, and says,  "You wrote
  | _that_? "
 
| thx wrote:
| my fav era with him was with Bob Dylan, 1966 -
| 
| here's a pretty niche video with both of them playing a Dylan
| song that never made an official album release
| 
|  _On A Rainy Afternoon_
| 
| https://youtu.be/qE3owtjQmSc
| 
| awesome guitarist / RIP
 
  | tnecniv wrote:
  | Bob Dylan talked about how he loved working with him because
  | he's the rare guitarist that had all the chops but didn't need
  | to show them off.
  | 
  | As an example, here's a clip of him playing with Clapton. He
  | takes over right when Clapton's strap slips off his guitar and
  | they go back and forth shredding.
  | 
  | https://youtu.be/1WDmMWF83x4
  | 
  | However, if you listen to him with Dylan or The Band, the
  | guitar parts are always simple and about fitting the song.
 
    | ubermonkey wrote:
    | That's a pretty famous clip -- it's from The Last Waltz, if
    | I'm not mistaken -- but I first heard it on Clapton's 1988
    | career-retrospective box set _Crossroads_. Back then, the
    | video was harder to come by, so my fellow guitar-nerds and I
    | didn 't actually realize the hows or whys of the handoff
    | until years later.
    | 
    | You can actually SEE that the strap was in a precarious
    | position in the clip (it's clear at like 45s). Straps in that
    | era didn't have strap locks. It'd just be a chunky post in
    | the guitar, and a leather tab at the end of your strap you'd
    | force over it. In a normal orientation, it'd be secure
    | ENOUGH, but as shown it's been flipped over, which means the
    | weight of the guitar itself is pushing on it in a way that
    | will absolutely cause the guitar to slip out of it.
 
| AlbertCory wrote:
| There's a free movie, _Once Were Brothers_ you should watch, for
| his biography.
 
| masom wrote:
| It would be nice if the post title would include the article
| title, I didn't know who was Robbie Robertson, what they did, and
| why it might be relevant.
| 
| https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
 
  | igrekel wrote:
  | [flagged]
 
  | eterm wrote:
  | Well, if we're going by the news guidelines then most
  | obituaries mostly fall foul of the principle:
  | 
  | > "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports,
  | or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new
  | phenomenon"
  | 
  | It feels a bit tasteless to expand further on this, especially
  | in this thread, so I typically just flag and move on.
 
  | Vvector wrote:
  | "Robbie Robertson, Guitarist and Songwriter With the Band, Dies
  | at 80"
 
    | [deleted]
 
  | 1vuio0pswjnm7 wrote:
  | You mean like this perhaps:
  | 
  | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37072982
  | 
  | The HN software tries to "auto-correct" and so "The Band"
  | becomes "the Band". Incorrect.
 
    | capableweb wrote:
    | You can edit HN titles after submitting them, and it won't
    | auto-correct when editing.
 
      | 1vuio0pswjnm7 wrote:
      | If you catch it quick, yes. But it's quite easy to get
      | locked out of editing soon after submission.
 
| john_cogs wrote:
| "Now I don't mind choppin' wood. And I don't care if the money's
| no good."
| 
| RIP.
 
| te_chris wrote:
| RIP to an absolute legend. There's an excellent doc on Netflix
| rn.
 
| DoodahMan wrote:
| Played The Band's Academy of Music performance [0] last night
| when I got the news. It's right up there with The Last Waltz.
| Great and timeless music. Hell some of my favorite Grateful Dead
| performances were covers of his music. RIP Robbie. Enjoy your
| weekends fellow heady folks (~);)
| 
| [0] -
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNtcW2LqveU&list=OLAK5uy_khf...
 
  | dogman144 wrote:
  | My favorite music lore is the Dead, The Band, Dylan and Lennon
  | interplayed.
  | 
  | - the The Dead covering Dylan live consistently
  | 
  | - the Dead's weight covers over the years. I'm fairly Brent
  | Mydland's last-ish live song was the Weight and he sang the
  | "I've gotta go but my friends can stick around" verse. Chilling
  | but feels right.
  | 
  | - Jerry and the Dead supporting Dylan with a joint tour in the
  | 80's when Dylan was a washed up alcoholic
  | 
  | - Jerry's got a great Dear Prudence cover that I believe yoko
  | said it was how the song was meant to be played. Plus a bunch
  | of other JCB/Dylan covers.
  | 
  | True musicians!
 
  | phirschybar wrote:
  | Greatest live album of all time IMHO
 
| dundarious wrote:
| RIP. Recently heard this interview with him, telling a story not
| actually about himself, but still revealing a lot about himself
| and what making blues music was like at that time.
| 
| Robbie Robertson Talks About Sonny Boy Williamson (Language
| Warning) https://youtu.be/90-O6c20PLk
 
| karaokeyoga wrote:
| https://archive.md/vxISM
 
| 11thEarlOfMar wrote:
| ...the wind just kind of pushed me this way.
 
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2023-08-10 23:00 UTC)