[HN Gopher] J. Kenji Lopez-Alt says you're cooking just fine
___________________________________________________________________
 
J. Kenji Lopez-Alt says you're cooking just fine
 
Author : nkurz
Score  : 143 points
Date   : 2022-02-27 13:26 UTC (9 hours ago)
 
web link (www.newyorker.com)
w3m dump (www.newyorker.com)
 
| francislata wrote:
| I love Kenji's cooking videos! You definitely learn a lot. I love
| how he brings his experiences and knowledge learned into his
| recipes. I remember watching a Japanese Chicken Katsu video of
| his, and the fact that he compares how salting affects the
| juicyness of the final product gives a simple homecook the
| knowledge they need to know that can possibly be applied to some
| other recipe later on.
 
| gullywhumper wrote:
| Kenji's channel and writing are great windows into how cooking
| does not need to follow rigid rules and precise measurements to
| make great food. He substitutes ingredients and uses what he has
| on hand all the time. Unless it's something like bread or pizza
| dough, where he needs the correct ratio between flour and water,
| he never measures or weighs anything. He frequently leaves
| something baking in the oven or simmering on the stovetop,
| promising to come back in X minutes, but it's usually Y minutes
| later because he's been off doing something with his
| wife/kid/dogs. It seems like he says things like "oops" and "but
| that's ok" a lot. Cooking shouldn't be intimidating. He shows how
| approachable and forgiving it can be.
 
  | gyc wrote:
  | Yeah I got a kick out of watching his videos and seeing him
  | every so often pull out some slightly wilted vegetables to make
  | his dish. Quite the contrast to seeing all the pristine
  | ingredients on TV cooking shows.
 
  | mabbo wrote:
  | He has an episode in which he absolutely mangles his pizza and
  | it looks horrendous.
  | 
  | He literally says while recording "Doesn't matter, still pizza.
  | Actually, that's what I'm going to name this episode."
  | 
  | It doesn't matter that it was very not Instagram-worthy. What
  | matters is that it's still pizza and he's still going to feed
  | his family with it.
 
| dylanz wrote:
| I've been watching Kenji's YouTube channel for quite a while and
| it's one of my favorite channels. One of his favorite chefs is
| Jacque Pepin (and mine!) and it shows. He's not pretentious,
| mellow, substitutes ingredients the recipe calls for with
| ingredients he actually has in his house, and geeks out on
| history and science. Lastly his dogs are pretty darn cute and get
| to taste some great dishes.
 
  | dvtrn wrote:
  | I get way too excited about the end of the videos for the
  | summoning of his four-legged food tasters :)
 
  | aniforprez wrote:
  | I've found Ethan Chlebowski and Kenji's videos really put in a
  | lot of great, simple tips that make for some good cooking. For
  | the most part, their videos aren't necessarily about the dish
  | itself but the processes whilst cooking them. Kenji's boiling
  | eggs video and Ethan's risotto-like pasta video have helped me
  | immensely and just watching them cook has added some great
  | techniques to my own repertoire. It really does help that
  | they're quite honest about making mistakes and tend to include
  | how and why they failed sometimes
 
    | kenneth wrote:
    | I watch an absurd amount of cooking YouTube, and I follow a
    | bunch of creators for different reasons. They each have their
    | appeal:
    | 
    | - Kenji - got into him because of Food Lab optimization
    | articles, but discovered I enjoyed the unique perspective of
    | his food videos done in real-time first-person
    | 
    | - Alex (french guy cooking) - basically a YouTube native
    | version of Kenji's food lab where he does series where he
    | goes really deep into topics beyond just the recipe level,
    | but really figuring out every aspect that affects a dish or
    | style of cooking. He also does a ton of custom builds to test
    | his ideas.
    | 
    | - Adam Ragusea - incredibly practical home cooking,
    | optimizing for what the average person might care about vs.
    | doing things "right" -- combined with deep dives into various
    | scientific topics, aided by interviews with experts (usually
    | college professors). The recipe videos are good for getting a
    | sense of how he throws things together on the fly
    | 
    | - Pro Home Cooks - he focuses on making everything from
    | scratch, which is interesting in dishes where people would
    | use pre-made components (bread, pickles, noodles, etc.)
    | 
    | - Joshua Weissman - very entertaining, highly ridiculous,
    | with various series focused on affordable foods, recreating
    | fast foods concepts, etc. makes a lot of things from scratch
    | 
    | - Ethan - comes up with some interesting novel techniques,
    | and is highly specifics in his recipes an outcomes, focused
    | on healthy food. He certainly has his quirks which can get a
    | bit grating, but he's very consistent in what he produces.
    | 
    | - Babish - almost purely entertainment and less educational,
    | but well produced videos
    | 
    | - About To Eat - also has some interesting series, like the
    | ones focusing on specific ingredients, tools, or techniques
    | 
    | - Epicurious - has interesting series pitting amateur cooks
    | vs. chefs that end up showing various levels of complexity of
    | the same dishes
    | 
    | - Muchnie "why we eat" - experienced chefs explain the
    | cultural roots and history of dishes while showing how
    | they're made
    | 
    | etc. etc.... I watch too much food YouTube.
 
      | kenneth wrote:
      | Oh and another I forgot to mention that's a favorite is
      | "Not another cooking show" by a NYC creator who perfectly
      | makes videos of primarily Italian-American fare. Love the
      | way he edits.
 
      | theshrike79 wrote:
      | I'd like to add one of my smaller favourites: Internet
      | Shaquille[0], his videos are short and to the point and
      | highly un-pretentious.
      | 
      | [0] https://www.youtube.com/c/internetshaquille
 
      | skyyler wrote:
      | Since other people are linking their favorites to this
      | comment, I thought I'd add mine:
      | 
      | https://www.youtube.com/c/middleeats
      | 
      | Middle Eastern / Levantine cuisines don't get enough love
      | on YouTube (or in English speaking spaces in general) so I
      | love learning about new dishes through Obi's well made
      | videos.
 
      | awild wrote:
      | This list is pretty good, though I've found Alex to be
      | quite grating and very low on the information side of
      | things for a long time(that noodle tier list was an absurd
      | waste of time). Still sometimes entertaining to watch and I
      | just yesterday cooked the carbonara he outlined in his last
      | video.
      | 
      | There is also "My name is andong" who is really good imho.
      | Informative and fun, more trying to showcase new things or
      | in different lights.
      | 
      | There's also Chef John who is one of the OG food tubers.
      | His narration style is a 1:1 template for how Joshua
      | weissman talks in a lot of his recipes. He's mostly on the
      | recipe side less on information but still enjoyable.
 
      | dharmon wrote:
      | Probably my favorite, that you're missing on this list
      | (mostly likely cause his channel only recently "blew up"),
      | is Brian Lagerstrom, formerly called Weeds & Sardines.
      | Another recent fave is Middle Eats. I probably make his
      | lentil fatteh recipe every couple of weeks.
      | 
      | I tend to avoid cooking "entertainment" a la Babish and
      | Weissman. Weissman is frustrating cause it used to be a
      | legit cooking channel, but at some point a few years ago he
      | stopped trying to make recipes that you would actually want
      | to eat and focused on food porn. Then he got super lazy
      | where you can tell he doesn't even test his recipes before
      | filming.
 
        | kenneth wrote:
        | Actually I recently discovered Brian Lagerstrom and have
        | enjoyed his videos so far, but I haven't been watching
        | him for long hence my forgetfulness. Good call.
 
      | jgable wrote:
      | It's funny, I actually find Babish quite educational
      | because his videos are so tightly edited. Explains the
      | techniques and recipe in seven minutes flat. My wife and I
      | have made many of his recipes (that he usually borrows from
      | others) because he makes them so appealing, shows common
      | mistakes, and does it so _quickly_.
 
      | dylanz wrote:
      | This list is awesome. Thanks for posting it!
 
      | clove wrote:
      | You should check out Jack Scalfani (Cooking with Jack). He
      | cooks stuff you'll never see from the guys you've listed.
 
      | tmoertel wrote:
      | If you follow those creators, you may want to try Glen And
      | Friends Cooking
      | (https://www.youtube.com/c/GlenAndFriendsCooking) for
      | interesting takes on cooking and recipes, with new episodes
      | every few days. The subjects are fascinating and vary
      | widely, but they do have some regular segments.
      | 
      | On Sundays, for example, they do "The Old Cookbook Show,"
      | in which they pick quirky recipes from old cookbooks,
      | typically 50 to 100 years old, but sometimes going back
      | centuries. They cook the recipes and then describe how the
      | resulting dishes taste--sometimes with disastrous results
      | but other times with the rediscovery of a forgotten dish.
      | For example, one recent epsiode is on a "100 Year Old
      | Mississippi Cheese Pie Recipe," believed to be the
      | precursor of the "chess pie" of southern United States
      | fame.
 
| 0xbadcafebee wrote:
| > How do I, as someone who's not Chinese--I'm half Japanese, I
| grew up in the U.S.--write all this stuff about Chinese recipes
| with any authority? Why should people trust me? And why is it
| O.K. for me to be doing this?
| 
| Why do the Chinese get to wield supreme executive authority over
| throwing some random ingredients into a thin pan on high heat?
| What kind of Food Holocaust do people think is going to happen if
| some random food blogger who isn't Chinese writes about woks?
| Chinese food (as if you could say exactly what is and isn't Real
| Chinese Food without starting a Food Holy War) isn't going to be
| obliterated by it.
| 
| The whole cultural appropriation thing is dead to me at this
| point. Yes, your book's sales might tank if some lunatic with
| millions of fans decides to excoriate you for being ignorant or
| disrespectful to some cultural trope like "the right way to stir-
| fry" or something. But they might also ignore you. I don't think
| it's worth giving yourself anxiety just to make sure you "have
| the right" to write about some subject. Just try to be a good
| person, do your work, and stay off of Twitter.
 
| luxurytent wrote:
| Kenji shines on his YouTube channel. He has a fantastic
| capability to teach in a fun, nurturing manner that almost feels
| dad-like (this is reflected in many of the comments on his
| videos). I view myself as a pretty seasoned home-cook but I
| always learn a thing or two from his videos. Recommend!
 
  | ethbr0 wrote:
  | The biggest thing I love about his videos is both showing and
  | highlighting the interstitial moments.
  | 
  | A huge amount of cooking isn't actually cooking, but counter
  | space management, dishwashing, measuring, etc. Doing that well
  | makes cooking easy and enjoyable, as time becomes less limited.
  | Screwing it up multiplies stress by orders of magnitude. Zen,
  | indeed.
 
    | yissp wrote:
    | The head-mounted-camera format he uses is a big part of that,
    | I think. Seeing the process from the perspective of the cook
    | really gives you a good sense of everything involved.
 
| jt2190 wrote:
| > _But, even before that, I remember when I first started
| thinking about the way I behaved. I was still living in Boston. I
| had been out of kitchens for a couple years. I think I was
| working at Cook's Illustrated. I had two roommates in Cambridge--
| one of them was my best friend. She and I had lived together
| since college. We had a friend visiting, and my roommate had
| woken up, gone to the corner store, and bought a box of pancake
| mix and was making pancakes. I came out of my room that morning
| and basically just berated her about using pancake mix when we
| had all the ingredients already. Our mutual friend was, like,
| "Kenji, you're being an asshole. Why are you judging a person for
| making pancakes?" And I realized at that point, Oh, crap, why am
| I belittling one of my best friends in the world for wanting to
| make pancakes at home? I had to make a conscious decision not to
| be that way._
| 
| > _You can train yourself, I think, to be a better person just by
| thinking about it a lot, and acting on those thoughts._
 
  | tayo42 wrote:
  | I liked his stuff, he really can be an asshole on reddit (and
  | Twitter which he deleted). Kind of turned me off to him.
 
    | ricardobeat wrote:
    | His last tweet seems pretty fitting to your comment:
    | 
    | > Be good to each other. Stop arguing in short bursts and
    | getting mad at strangers because they had to trim complex
    | thoughts down to a single sentence. Make your words
    | meaningful, rather than clever. Call someone you love or
    | someone you don't and have a conversation. Quit this.
 
      | sdb0 wrote:
      | Why take advice from someone who doesn't even follow it
 
        | BenjiWiebe wrote:
        | If it's good advice, does it truly matter if the giver
        | follows it?
 
        | sdb0 wrote:
        | So far it has worked for 0 out of the 1 people we know
        | who've tried it. Maybe it's not good advice
 
    | plandis wrote:
    | I've only recently gotten into Kenji but he doesn't come off
    | as an asshole to me. Perhaps he's grown up a bit since you
    | last read/watch him?
 
      | tayo42 wrote:
      | According to the article maybe(especially if he's drinking
      | less), I don't really seek out his stuff. I formed my
      | opinion after he showed up and started something responding
      | to a comment on reddit about recipes that had nothing to do
      | with him.
 
    | whimsicalism wrote:
    | Yes, I've actually had a (what I intended to be friendly)
    | conversation with him on twitter where he was definitely an
    | asshole. Glad he is becoming more introspective (or it was
    | just an off morning for him).
 
    | Aunche wrote:
    | This is consistent with the above quote. Someone who's
    | naturally somewhat of an asshole has to always actively keep
    | that in check to be nice. Other people are naturally
    | pleasant.
 
  | [deleted]
 
  | zinclozenge wrote:
  | I used to be anti mix. Now I'm 100% on the train. The simple
  | fact is that the extra stabilizers and emulsifiers that are
  | added to the mix don't detract from the flavor and texture at
  | all, if anything enhancing the texture. Mixes are engineered to
  | consistently reach a desired result. Krusteez pancake mix is a
  | permanent staple in my house. If I feel like baking something
  | like brownies, or a cake I'll go out to buy a mix on my next
  | shopping trip. Cookies are probably the only thing I won't
  | bother due to their simplicity.
 
    | wheels wrote:
    | For folks with no actual interest in cooking, and who live in
    | a place with obnoxiously large kitchens (i.e. USA), they're
    | fine. Also, it helps to be well off, as they're basically a
    | scheme to mark up simple ingredients by a significant
    | multiplier.
    | 
    | People that are interested in cooking are going to have that
    | stuff around, aren't going to be put off by 60 seconds of
    | measuring things out, and like the ability to tweek the
    | composition -- plus making things from basic ingredients
    | increases the understanding of how ingredients work.
    | 
    | Also, for those of us without ginormous kitchens (mine is
    | huge by urban European standards, tiny by suburban American),
    | there's just a limit on how much stuff you can store that you
    | can reliably recreate in under a minute.
 
      | sasawpg wrote:
      | > plus making things from basic ingredients increases the
      | understanding of how ingredients work.
      | 
      | That's a bit of a stretch. Following a recipe doesn't
      | necessarily imply you understand how ingredients work.
      | 
      | I would say I'm an "above average" cook (define as you
      | will), and yet I still use Krusteez pancake mix. They're
      | very good from the mix and I'd prefer to waste my time
      | scrolling endlessly or other crap instead (I'm not fooling
      | anyone, time saved making pancakes from scratch is entirely
      | time wasted elsewhere).
 
        | wheels wrote:
        | The "wasting time" is literally adding three spoons of
        | stuff to flour. (Two for me since I use a full package of
        | baking powder.) It's literally in the 30 seconds range.
        | If you were doing it a lot, you could even pre-mix them
        | in those 30 seconds, and have enough for as many batches
        | as you cared. It's a pretty weird micro-optimization.
        | 
        | You don't learn about how the ingredients work by making
        | one thing from a recipe, but you do if you make a bunch
        | of related things from similar ingredients. On the bread
        | / cake spectrum, one learns to pretty reliably
        | distinguish between things based on leavening agent and
        | if they contain eggs.
        | 
        | Also, I wouldn't say that most above average home cook
        | actually has much interest in cooking. But the average J.
        | Kenji Lopez-Alt fan does. Most people cook because they
        | need to eat. What I'm calling "interest" I'm imagining
        | people where it's at least a hobby -- there's active
        | effort in improving one's understanding of it and
        | technique.
 
        | [deleted]
 
    | globular-toast wrote:
    | I was confused when you mentioned that cookies are simpler
    | than pancakes, then I remembered: _American_ pancakes. I was
    | thinking _crepes_ which is literally just flour, eggs, milk,
    | butter and salt. The  "mix" is literally just flour.
 
      | bobthepanda wrote:
      | American pancakes are the same with the addition of baking
      | powder.
      | 
      | Though if you're making buttermilk pancakes I would imagine
      | most people do not have buttermilk on hand if they're not
      | baking.
 
      | qbasic_forever wrote:
      | I would bet the average American that says they 'cook' are
      | actually just taking frozen meals like pizzas, chicken
      | tenders, biscuits in a can, etc. and heating them in the
      | oven. Households don't typically have even have flour,
      | fresh milk, butter or other staples on hand here.
 
    | ericmcer wrote:
    | I swear bisquick is my favorite pancake, it has some
    | intangible quality that I can't replicate with household
    | ingredients. That said I make sourdough pancakes for health,
    | but I totally agree that flavor wise, mixes taste fine.
 
    | sasawpg wrote:
    | I used to be anti pancake mix as well. Then I got a cabin
    | where pancakes are almost a mandatory weekend breakfast and I
    | realized I often forget to bring fresh ingredients (mainly
    | milk). Krusteez was a hit and I became a convert.
 
    | tootie wrote:
    | Pancake mix is my one and only bugaboo. The fact that you
    | need your own eggs and milk mean the box is basically saving
    | you from adding a bit of salt, sugar and baking soda to
    | flour. Ingredients I always have on hand. And while I've
    | never done a taste test for pancakes, I'm very loyal to King
    | Arthur flour.
 
      | jfengel wrote:
      | It was a famous result that cooks rejected early mixes that
      | required just water. Snopes marks it as "false" but there's
      | enough of a grain of truth to it to make it relevant:
      | 
      | https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/something-eggstra/
      | 
      | I too find it weird that people buy that when it's so easy
      | at home, with ingredients most people have. I suppose if
      | you never bake you don't have flour or baking powder on
      | hand. Eggs and milk are something everyone has.
 
    | Xylakant wrote:
    | > Mixes are engineered to consistently reach a desired
    | result.
    | 
    | That's pretty much exactly what I dislike about mixes and
    | ready-made food. It's not that they're bad, but they are the
    | same every time. Your pancakes taste like my pancakes. That's
    | boring. I like tasting other peoples pancakes. I usually
    | stock some ready to eat food for times when cooking is just
    | not and option, but I rarely end up reaching for it.
    | 
    | Also, they're single use, they can not be disassembled to
    | build something else. With eggs, milk, flour, butter, I can
    | make pancakes - American and German style, Dutch Baby,
    | Kaiserschmarrn, waffles, ... A pancake mix is a pancake mix,
    | it's pancakes, nothing else.
 
      | MisterBastahrd wrote:
      | It's almost as if you can tweak mixes or something.
      | 
      | Seriously, you want to change pancake mix? Use some
      | buttermilk instead of milk. Mix in a bit of sourdough
      | starter. Add some fruit. Cook down a can of fruit with some
      | sugar and lemon juice and make your own syrup. There are
      | tons of things you can do.
      | 
      | If I go to a fancy restaurant that specializes in pancakes,
      | THEN I expect them to do their own thing. But waking up at
      | morning and getting pancakes that someone has prepared for
      | me is better than waking up in the morning and eating a
      | bowl of cereal or a pre-wrapped muffin. MOST people don't
      | have a go-to pancake recipe... they'd just look up and use
      | the first thing they found online that they had ingredients
      | for.
 
        | Xylakant wrote:
        | Let's not get religious about it - it's food and you do
        | what you do. I'll eat your pancakes, mix or not. But the
        | parent I was responding to was extolling consistency as a
        | virtue and I don't consider consistency (as in "tastes
        | the same every time", as opposed to "tastes great every
        | time") a great thing.
        | 
        | And if you start adding sourdough to anything,
        | consistency goes straight out the window. At least my
        | sourdough is anything but consistent.
 
        | MisterBastahrd wrote:
        | You can straight up use the sour dough starter that you
        | would normally throw away as scallion pancake mix.
        | Seriously, just pour it onto a greased pan and throw
        | scallions on the other side, then flip and cook til done.
 
        | Xylakant wrote:
        | Yes, I know. But my point was that sourdough, at least
        | the one I keep, are living things and are not
        | consistently the same. Mine depends on the time I kept it
        | in the fridge, the temperature it's kept outside (which
        | depends on the weather), on how active the last
        | generation was and many other factors I have more or less
        | under control. And that manifests in taste difference,
        | raising power etc.
 
        | kwhitefoot wrote:
        | If you have all that on hand why would you not have eggs,
        | flour, and milk as well?
 
        | sasawpg wrote:
        | As nobody in my household drinks white milk, I only have
        | it on hand if a recipe specifically calls for it. And I
        | suspect they wouldn't quite be the same with chocolate
        | milk, of which there is almost always a supply thanks to
        | kids ..
 
        | wheels wrote:
        | I would assume mixing in buttermilk for milk would mess
        | things up since it messes with the acid ratios, which is
        | one of the things that really matters in baked goods with
        | chemical leavening agents. Usually something with only
        | milk would use baking powder, whereas something with
        | buttermilk would use some portion of baking soda.
 
        | vinceguidry wrote:
        | 100%. I used to cook a lot from scratch. I had a few
        | things that I made a lot and knew how to balance the
        | flavors of. Then when I suddenly found myself with a lot
        | less time to cook, but still with the same picky taste
        | buds, I started buying premade, prepackaged TV dinners
        | from Publix and Whole Foods and doctoring them up with
        | added spices, or chopping an onion or pepper to add to
        | it, after microwaving them for half the time to defrost
        | them.
        | 
        | Like, you can buy anything and make it good.
 
      | vanusa wrote:
      | _Your pancakes taste like my pancakes. That's boring. I
      | like tasting other peoples pancakes._
      | 
      | Then again, some people just want to make reasonably good
      | pancakes for their kids or before heading off to work,
      | without too much thought or effort. Or having to be
      | "creative" or think about how they compare with other
      | people's pancakes. Are you OK with that?
 
        | Xylakant wrote:
        | Look, I'm not advocating banning pancake mixes or canned
        | or frozen food. I absolutely understand that people have
        | constraints and not everyone has the time or energy to
        | cook every day. I just say that I personally, don't
        | consider "it consistently produces the same result." a
        | good thing in all cases. Are you OK with that?
 
        | vanusa wrote:
        | That's great, of course. Bon appetit.
        | 
        | I was just trying to get back to the point of the
        | original article.
 
    | js2 wrote:
    | We make a batch of Alton Brown's mix maybe every other month:
    | 
    | https://altonbrown.com/recipes/semi-instant-pancake-mix/
    | 
    | I don't think we have any trouble with consistency.
    | 
    | For baking, my go to recipe site is Smitten Kitchen.
    | 
    | It's not that we're anti-mix, it's that it's easy to stock
    | the staple baking ingredients and then we can make whatever
    | we want.
 
| ngngngng wrote:
| I haven't read his book or followed him online extensively, but I
| credit Kenji with my first breakthrough in cooking food that was
| better than what I can get in a quality restaurant. His "Late
| Night Cheeseburger" video produced one of the best hamburgers
| I've ever eaten, and I made it myself!
| 
| Since then I've been cooking a lot more for myself, mostly using
| Joshua Weissman's recipe's. His videos get annoying quickly (lots
| of overdone, repetitive, "meme" humor) but his recipes include
| exact seasoning amounts and the low end cooking time he lists is
| always perfect, never overcooked.
| 
| My mother cooked almost every night for us as children, but when
| I eat her cooking now I'm almost always shocked at how
| underseasoned and overcooked everything is. I'm not sure most
| people know how to follow "season to taste", they just throw some
| salt in and set the table without tasting anything, and keep some
| good ol' iodized salt in a shaker handy.
 
  | mabbo wrote:
  | Joshua Weissman has brilliant information that adults want to
  | know, packaged in a format designed to make adults want to
  | murder Joshua Weissman.
  | 
  | I believe it's some kind of social experiment. Like his entire
  | online persona is an experiment.
 
    | ngngngng wrote:
    | > I believe it's some kind of social experiment. Like his
    | entire online persona is an experiment.
    | 
    | I like the theory, though as someone that's been exploring
    | content creation I really think it's often just necessary to
    | act different to stand out. Often that's just narcissism
    | though if I had to pick between narcissism and weirdness I'll
    | take weirdness.
 
| mhb wrote:
| 130 degrees inside? I don't think so. Seems like a New Yorker
| mistake.
 
  | 88913527 wrote:
  | I remove from the oven between 115 to 120 degrees, then let
  | rest for 5 minutes under foil. Let carryover cooking do the
  | remaining work. Then pan sear for about 2-3 minutes, flipping
  | occasionally, spooning butter and the rendered fat over the
  | meat.
 
  | chabons wrote:
  | From someone with no knowledge of reverse sear: Why does that
  | seem like a mistake? 130F is how you get medium rare with a
  | sous-vide setup. If you're talking long and slow using an oven,
  | it seems reasonable to me that you'd aim for the same internal
  | temp as sous-vide.
 
    | mhb wrote:
    | From his Cook's Illustrated recipe:
    | 
    |  _Cook until instant-read thermometer inserted in center of
    | steak registers 90 to 95 degrees for rare to medium-rare, 20
    | to 25 minutes, or 100 to 105 degrees for medium, 25 to 30
    | minutes._
    | 
    | https://www.cooksillustrated.com/recipes/3564-pan-seared-
    | thi...
 
    | karlshea wrote:
    | The original reverse sear recipe is 115deg for med-rare,
    | 125deg for med, assuming you're gonna pump a lot more heat
    | into it getting the crust (plus carryover).
    | 
    | Edit: to maybe answer your actual question, I think sous vide
    | has a different goal. Different final textures, maybe more
    | refined? Reverse sear is more fixing the common "the outside
    | looked good but the inside is raw" problem if you don't have
    | a lot of steak experience.
    | 
    | I think if you were going to crust up a sous vide steak on a
    | charcoal grill you'd probably want to cook it at 115-125 as
    | well.
 
      | mandeepj wrote:
      | > the outside looked good but the inside is raw
      | 
      | make sure you don't start cooking it right away after
      | taking out from the refrigerator. I normally let it rest
      | for 30-45 mins, sometimes even an hour.
 
        | balfirevic wrote:
        | Incidentally, that does almost nothing according to this
        | article by... Kenji Lopez!
        | https://www.seriouseats.com/old-wives-tales-about-
        | cooking-st...
 
        | karlshea wrote:
        | Agree, that really helps!
 
    | rootusrootus wrote:
    | > 130F is how you get medium rare with a sous-vide setup
    | 
    | This also depends on what cut the steak is. 138F is a better
    | target for something with more fat, like ribeye, because 130F
    | won't really break it down.
 
  | [deleted]
 
  | rootusrootus wrote:
  | For what cut of steak, what method? E.g. sous vide ribeye works
  | best at 138F, every time. But other cuts are better a little
  | cooler. And reverse sear is not sous vide. Etc.
 
  | throw0101a wrote:
  | > _3. Place steak(s) in the oven and cook until an instant-read
  | thermometer registers 105degF (41degC) for rare, 115degF
  | (46degC) for medium-rare, 125degF (52degC) for medium, or
  | 135degF (57degC) for medium-well. This will take about 20
  | minutes for rare steak and up to about 40 minutes for medium-
  | well; cooking time can vary dramatically depending on many
  | factors, so check often._
  | 
  | * https://www.seriouseats.com/reverse-seared-steak-recipe
  | 
  | * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pO8TUuSv7HA&t=3m10s
  | 
  | ~130F / 55C is not crazy.
 
| xdfgh1112 wrote:
| Kenji's cooking methods are always 10x more effort for 10% better
| food. Great for supertasters, not necessary for most of us.
 
  | resoluteteeth wrote:
  | > Kenji's cooking methods are always 10x more effort for 10%
  | better food. Great for supertasters, not necessary for most of
  | us.
  | 
  | I think he may have that tendency somewhat but it's not as
  | nearly as bad as some other places like Cook's Illustrated
  | (where I guess he used to work) which really tend to add
  | unnecessary steps for very small improvements.
  | 
  | At serious eats he sometimes made multiple versions of recipes,
  | an easy version and a more complicated version, to make it
  | possible for people to decide which they want to make. On his
  | videos he often explains optional steps that can be omitted.
  | 
  | Also, FYI that's not really what "supertasters" means (it
  | doesn't mean people who have a discerning palate and can pick
  | out subtle flavors, it means people who are hypersensitive to
  | certain bitter flavors).
 
  | roughly wrote:
  | I think the divide is the craft & process vs the outcome. If
  | you like cooking as a hobby, Kenji's methods are fun. If you're
  | just cooking for an outcome, you're right, his methods aren't
  | the fastest. Think of it like any other weekend project you do
  | - odds are a generous application of money or existing
  | expertise gets the job done faster than you poking around and
  | trying stuff, but is that really the goal?
 
  | mabbo wrote:
  | Do you have an example of something he showed the takes 10X
  | longer?
  | 
  | I find most of his recommendations made me a faster cook.
 
    | qbasic_forever wrote:
    | Grinding your own bespoke mix of beef for a burger is a huge
    | increase in time and complexity for a burger:
    | https://www.seriouseats.com/the-burger-lab-the-worlds-
    | best-b...
    | 
    | Will it make an amazingly tasty burger? Yes.
    | 
    | Is it worth it when you want a burger on a late weeknight? It
    | depends.
 
  | qbasic_forever wrote:
  | That's just the food lab/serious eats stuff IMHO. Those things
  | are purpose built to be "what if we turned everything up to 11
  | and made the best possible X/Y/Z?". If you read Modernist
  | Cuisine it's exactly the same thing and you'll spend two days
  | making a single cheeseburger (with from scratch bread, cheese,
  | mayo, grinding your own beef, sous vide cooking the patty for
  | hours, etc).
  | 
  | Watch his youtube channel and more recent stuff, it's a lot
  | more toned down and accessible to everyone.
 
  | tshaddox wrote:
  | To some extent, yeah, the whole point is to exert more effort
  | to get better food, although I suspect your numbers are
  | exaggerated (10x sounds extreme). But I don't think many well
  | known chefs would recommend doing that if you _don't at least
  | somewhat enjoy the effort required to cook_.
 
  | jghn wrote:
  | I've seen him state that he doesn't expect people to do all of
  | the extra labor intensive steps. He's showing you all the
  | things you can do and how they enhance, you choose how far you
  | want to take it.
  | 
  | I've been following his stuff since the aughts. At this point I
  | almost never make his recipes as stated. I've learned which
  | techniques I find worth it, which I don't, and in others I've
  | folded in things he came up with later on his own journey
 
| kaycebasques wrote:
| I'll put in a plug for some friends of friends. Check out
| Backhaus if you're ever around San Mateo. Gourmet bread and
| pastries and whatnot. J. Kenji Lopez-Alt is one of their
| financial backers / advisers [1].
| 
| [1]
| https://mobile.twitter.com/kenjilopezalt/status/104862447412...
 
  | isatty wrote:
  | Or Wursthall in San Mateo, which is his restaurant. The food is
  | excellent.
 
    | donarb wrote:
    | Kenji is no longer an owner at Wursthall.
 
      | karlding wrote:
      | Yeah, see Kenji's comment on /r/seriouseats [0]:
      | 
      |  _> I am not an owner any longer! I gave my shares to my
      | former Sous chef Erik who still lives in the area. My
      | involvement at Wursthall is only a friendly one, not a
      | business one at this point._
      | 
      | However, in the same thread Kenji also says the following
      | [1]:
      | 
      |  _> it's still my recipes (and one of Stella's!) there, as
      | well as quite a few Serious Eats-inspired techniques._
      | 
      | [0] https://reddit.com/r/seriouseats/comments/oszuh0/made_i
      | t_to_...
      | 
      | [1] https://reddit.com/r/seriouseats/comments/oszuh0/made_i
      | t_to_...
 
    | peferron wrote:
    | I went to Wursthall twice and found it to be mediocre.
    | Backhaus is indeed excellent, and in a completely different
    | league.
 
      | tshaddox wrote:
      | I'm not particularly picky or discerning at all when it
      | comes to restaurants, but I also found Wursthall to be
      | mediocre. I didn't try the sausages, so maybe that was my
      | mistake.
 
      | chrisdhoover wrote:
      | Yes, mediocre and derivative.
 
| ripper1138 wrote:
| I was into his videos for a few months but I couldn't stand how
| much of a narcissist he is. He literally says he invented the
| reverse-searing technique.
 
  | mabbo wrote:
  | Did you read the article at all?
  | 
  | > do remember some folks taking issue with the idea that the
  | reverse sear was your creation.
  | 
  | > There's a competition barbecue team, Iron Pig BBQ, who were
  | doing a similar technique, but it wasn't published anywhere.
  | After we published it at Cook's Illustrated, some people were,
  | like, "Oh, yeah, this chef is doing it." There were people
  | concurrently doing it. The more generous claim would be that I
  | independently came up with the idea, and certainly Cook's
  | Illustrated popularized it.
  | 
  | How is this narcissistic?
 
| NelsonMinar wrote:
| For fellow MIT nerds you might enjoy this article about Kenji
| from Feb 2020 in The Tech https://thetech.com/2020/02/20/kenji-
| lopez-alt
| 
| Enjoyed this article and how personal it was. Helen Rosner is a
| great writer.
 
| simonw wrote:
| I've been looking forward to his new book The Wok so much.
| 
| I've been following his stuff on Serious Eats (and The Food Lab
| book) for years. I've never had a recipe of his let me down.
 
  | tylerflick wrote:
  | The Food Lab is a must have for any kitchen. Best cookbook I've
  | ever owned.
 
  | AdmiralAsshat wrote:
  | Never had a recipe of his let me down, but his chicken adobo
  | recipe (where you simmer a sauce of sugar, soy sauce, and
  | vinegar for like an hour) practically destroyed my wok's
  | seasoning. The sauce was almost caramel like by the end of it,
  | which let to a ton of caked on burnt bits I could only scrape
  | off aggressively, and then the vinegar evaporation created what
  | I can only call steam bubbles in the patina that caused them to
  | flake off like paint chips. I had to pretty much scrape
  | everything off and start from scratch on reseasoning the wok
  | after that. It's still not quite back to what it was before
  | "the Adobo event" (as my girlfriend calls it).
  | 
  | Still a delicious recipe, but, I learned to use my deep saute
  | pan for it in the future.
 
    | mazelife wrote:
    | Yes, a wok is a somewhat strange choice for that dish. I'm
    | not really an "expert" on Pinoy food but my partner is
    | Filipino and I've seen this made many times by him, his
    | family, or even friends of his when we have visited the
    | Philippines and never once did a wok come into it. Either a
    | dutch oven our a large saucepan is what I've seen used, since
    | you really want to cover it so it braises evenly. The sauce
    | is always fairly thin as well, nothing approaching a
    | caramel-y consistency.
 
    | wonnage wrote:
    | If it's the one I'm thinking of then the first line of the
    | recipe is "Place the soy sauce, vinegar, garlic, black
    | peppercorns, and bay leaves in a large, nonreactive saute
    | pan", i.e not something that requires seasoning
 
  | jeffwilcox wrote:
  | So excited! We're seeing Kenji on Saturday in Seattle at a book
  | launch event, so cool seeing him get so much press and
  | excitement around all this.
 
  | anthomtb wrote:
  | Agreed. If anyone is looking to make a classic dish, browse
  | right to Serious Eats and avoid the SEO recipe spam on Google.
  | You'll save time, bypass the big-data overlord and end up with
  | better-than-restaurant quality food.
 
    | rustyfe wrote:
    | Worth calling out that Serious Eats is a publication with
    | many recipe developers. Not all of them are equal to Kenji
    | (although Daniel Gritzer is unequal because he's even
    | better!).
    | 
    | Serious Eats is overall great, but definitely trust the
    | byline not the publication.
 
      | simonw wrote:
      | +1 to Daniel Gritzer - but Serious Eats generally has
      | earned my trust now, they must have a really good editorial
      | process over there to keep the quality so high.
 
| eschneider wrote:
| Cooking is the Perl of life activities in that "There are many
| ways to do it." and we all tend to optimize for different things.
| 
| I live with people with dietary restrictions, so I tend to make
| everything from scratch because I optimize for not killing my
| housemates. But I have found it's an added advantage in that if
| I'm mostly getting staples and assembling things myself, I both
| have a simpler time shopping and much less trouble meal planning
| because I can late-bind what I'm making since I've got
| ingredients for most common (for our household :) meals handy.
| 
| But that doesn't mean mixes/pre-made stuff is bad. If it's
| optimal for you, go for it. :)
 
| chair6 wrote:
| Mmm, Kenji's really good scrambled eggs are really good (and
| really quick) .. https://youtube.com/watch?v=CXTnq7srJRs.
 
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2022-02-27 23:01 UTC)