[HN Gopher] Furiosa's Cat Feeder (2016)
___________________________________________________________________
 
Furiosa's Cat Feeder (2016)
 
Author : a_t48
Score  : 118 points
Date   : 2022-02-01 19:14 UTC (3 hours ago)
 
web link (blondihacks.com)
w3m dump (blondihacks.com)
 
| tantalor wrote:
| HAMMOND: Yes, yes, yes. That's why we're taking extreme
| precautions.
| 
| GRANT: Do they show intelligence? With their brain cavity...
| 
| MULDOON: They show extreme intelligence, even problem-solving
| intelligence. Especially the big one. We bred eight originally,
| but when she came in she took over the pride and killed all but
| two of the others. That one... when she looks at you, you can see
| she's working things out. That's why we have to feed them like
| this. She had them all attacking the fences when the feeders
| came.
| 
| SATTLER: But the fences are electrified though, right?
| 
| MULDOON: That's right, but they never attack the same place
| twice. They were testing the fences for weaknesses,
| systematically. They remember.
 
| protomyth wrote:
| Its amazing how the iteration of test and fix turns into armor
| plated cat feeders and armored-up code. You look at the end point
| and go "surely that wasn't necessary", but anyone who was around
| for the development knows that it was just the iterations
| dictating a crazy looking but complete solution.
 
| 323 wrote:
| Why google for 5 minutes when you can weld for 5 hours :)
| 
| https://petspruce.com/tamper-proof-automatic-cat-feeder/
| 
| https://felinefollower.com/top/tamper-proof-automatic-cat-fe...
| 
| Also, is this site hosted on a solar powered raspberry pi? It's
| down with 5 comments and 20 upvotes.
 
  | wlesieutre wrote:
  | Just because a cat feeder _says_ it 's cat proof doesn't mean
  | it _is_ cat proof
 
  | borski wrote:
  | The one she modified also said pet proof ;)
  | 
  | "PET-PROOF: The feeder is designed to keep prying paws from
  | sneaking food before scheduled mealtimes"
 
  | Smoosh wrote:
  | That first link has some weird repetitive text about the litter
  | box. Odd.
 
  | Nextgrid wrote:
  | Both these websites reek of SEO spam.
 
| dmitrygr wrote:
| A pretty fun read, but the site is struggling. If it does not
| load for you, here's a cache:
| https://web.archive.org/web/20210619021044/https://blondihac...
 
  | a_t48 wrote:
  | Whoops, sorry Quinn (if you see this)
 
    | andrewxdiamond wrote:
    | Quinn is a software engineer IRL, so she very well may!
 
      | a_t48 wrote:
      | I hope so. Quinn is very very indirectly related to me
      | getting into software engineering in the first place. :)
 
| RicoElectrico wrote:
| Do we know whether it's potentially possible to rewire cat
| behavior, or are their brains set in stone after some time?
| 
| - Like in the TFA, food insecurity
| 
| - Un-feralizing cats reliably
| 
| It seems that cats are odd one out with respect to adaptation.
| Dogs can have temporary issues when adapting to new owners or
| envinonments, but given some time they can cope. Even wild
| animals we don't consider domesticated can adapt better than
| cats.
 
  | stormbrew wrote:
  | I don't even know where to start with this. Do you really
  | believe cats are somehow uniquely incapable of adaptation or
  | learning?
  | 
  | House cats are, for whatever reason:                 - very
  | routine driven,       - very sensitive to food availability,
  | - get bored really easily.
  | 
  | This combination means that if you regularly disrupt those
  | things you force the cat to _constantly_ adapt. Most animals
  | (including humans!) don 't deal well with that.
  | 
  | Honestly I think most bad behavior for cats is that third
  | point. People think because they're smaller than dogs they're
  | ok with tiny uninteresting spaces but that's not really how
  | they work. Especially if you have more than one, but if you do
  | only have one then they're gonna get incredibly bored.
  | 
  | Anyways, in my house we have 4 cats and we managed to "train"
  | them into more or less free feeding from all being pretty food
  | insecure by just using rfid-controlled feeder bowls that only
  | open for the right cat, so there's some anecdata for being able
  | to change cat behaviour.
 
    | RicoElectrico wrote:
    | > This combination means that if you regularly disrupt those
    | things you force the cat to constantly adapt.
    | 
    | I did not imply regular disruption. But take this example - I
    | have read/heard about semi-feral cats which were regularly
    | fed for over a year by somebody before allowing to be
    | touched. At this rate you could make it so for wild animals
    | typically found at human settlements like squirrels and
    | corvids. So, no change after the beginning, yet it took a
    | year for the cat before realizing humans are friendly.
    | 
    | > Honestly I think most bad behavior for cats is that third
    | point. People think because they're smaller than dogs they're
    | ok with tiny uninteresting spaces but that's not really how
    | they work.
    | 
    | On that one I have to agree - some people are surprised their
    | cats ignore them, but they don't play, especially to spend
    | energy during the so called zoomies.
 
      | nonameiguess wrote:
      | > But take this example - I have read/heard about semi-
      | feral cats which were regularly fed for over a year by
      | somebody before allowing to be touched.
      | 
      | This is true of individual cats, but not at all for cats as
      | an entire species. I regularly feed semi-feral cats and
      | even took one in. There is tremendous variety in how long
      | it takes before they'll let you touch them. In some cases,
      | it's never. In some cases, it's right away. I'd reckon an
      | average case is maybe about a month. It presumably depends
      | heavily on individual personality plus whatever history of
      | trauma from other large animals and people they have
      | already experienced before they ever met you.
 
| darknavi wrote:
| > You might say I've won this battle. However I just spent 20
| hours armor-plating a cat feeder. I think we know who's really in
| control here, don't we?
| 
| The stuff we do for our pets.
| 
| I use this nifty feeder/hopper in conjunction with an outlet
| running ESPHome for scheduling:
| 
| https://superfeederstore.com/wall-mount-cat-feeder-csf-3xl-b...
| 
| It's dumb and it works great!
 
| h2odragon wrote:
| I half expect the cat to be securing a supply of explosives.
| "finally convinced her to give up" ... there's a touch of tragedy
| in that. "We had this lovely game, human, until you spoiled it."
 
| Sniffnoy wrote:
| (2016)
 
| hycaria wrote:
| I would've stopped at the part where the cat can make them fall
| one by one with her paw. Let her grab food that way, that will
| make her busy longer than when dropping the meals.
 
| jasone wrote:
| Previously discussed:
| 
| - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13230904
| 
| - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13271746
 
| podiki wrote:
| What a journey! My vet recommended more puzzle feeders and moving
| to get rid of the free dry food (I do wet food in morning/night),
| both to control how much the cat eats and to give them something
| to do. After all, in the wild food is not free, they have to hunt
| for it.
| 
| One they recommended was something like [0] which is what I've
| been using. Works pretty well in that most of the time the cat
| knows he can't get food from me (though smart enough to know I
| fill them up and hide them). Adds a little game and great if
| you'll be out of the house for a while. So there's no longer a
| bowl for dry food at all, he has to "hunt" for his mice. Though
| I'm guilty of sometimes giving some bonus food, I think it is a
| helpful system. I think he'd be all over an autofeeder just like
| in this story (already have to hide the big dry food bag as he'll
| get into it).
| 
| [0] https://docandphoebe.com/
 
  | mschuster91 wrote:
  | > both to control how much the cat eats
  | 
  | Get one Surefeed per cat and that's not a problem any more -
  | side benefit, you'll see when one cat suddenly eats less which
  | may be an indicator for toothache... which can escalate into
  | full-blown hepatolipidosis like it did with one of my old cats.
  | 
  | Invest 300EUR, save 3500EUR in veterinary ICU costs down the
  | road.
 
  | Steltek wrote:
  | Won't the cats swarm over you while you're filling the hunting
  | feeder or dispersing them through the house?
 
  | madaxe_again wrote:
  | I'm so grateful for our two - we just leave out big bowls of
  | dry food, they eat a bit here and there, never excessively, and
  | both are lean and happy. I figured it was because they were
  | secure that there would always be more food - and it seems to
  | be the case, as I recommended to a friend who was new to cats
  | that they do the same, and their guys behave likewise.
 
    | stormbrew wrote:
    | We have four cats and 2 of them require special food (kidney
    | and allergies), and of the other two one of them will eat any
    | food he can find most of the time while the other wanted to
    | be in control of her own food to the point where she would do
    | the thing where she scratched at the side of the bowl trying
    | to bury it, presumably to keep it from the other one.
    | 
    | So just leaving some bowls out didn't really work for them,
    | they'd constantly eat each others' food or eat everything as
    | quick as possible to keep it from the other cats, with
    | predictable (and gross) results.
    | 
    | We got feeder bowls that only open with the right RFID and
    | now they're all much happier and more food secure. Sadly
    | there's no good ones on the market I could find that do
    | _both_ automatic feeding and the rfid-gating, so we still
    | have to manually feed them but for the most part they don 't
    | care when we feed them anymore except sometimes in the
    | morning (which is the most likely time for them to run out of
    | food).
 
      | nsv wrote:
      | Seems like a cool DIY project if you get the time to do it!
 
    | technothrasher wrote:
    | > I figured it was because they were secure that there would
    | always be more food
    | 
    | I've lived with quite a few different cats in my day. It's
    | simply the individual cat. Some cats overeat if allowed, some
    | don't. It's certainly nice when you have one that doesn't,
    | but it's nothing you did if you have one that does.
 
  | amelius wrote:
  | The problem with this approach is that you'll have spilled bits
  | of cat food all around the house.
 
    | heyheyhey wrote:
    | Yep, had this problem with one of those "ball feeders". My
    | solution was to put it in bathtub.
 
      | kelnos wrote:
      | We have a ball feeder, but this ends up not being a
      | problem; he eats every scrap of the food that comes out,
      | even if there are smaller crumbs. I guess it helps that we
      | feed him on a wood floor, not carpet, too.
 
  | a_t48 wrote:
  | I wish I could feed mine wet - but one of them requires
  | specialized dry food (Ultramino) that doesn't come in wet :(
 
| 0x002A wrote:
| Thousands of years ago felines decided to domesticate the hoomans
| for two reasons: continuous and scheduled supply of food and door
| opening functionality on demand.
 
| tasha0663 wrote:
| I love the final look. Dirty steampunk art deco. Like something
| out of _BioShock_. Needs some barnacles.
 
| mousefad wrote:
| I sub to Quinn's youtube channel on the subject of metal
| machining, and recommend it if you're into that kind of thing.
| https://www.youtube.com/c/Blondihacks
| 
| Quinn is both a skilled maker and a wonderful teacher (not to
| mention having a superb wry sense of humour). The channel is one
| of the most informative places on "maker youtube". Quinn's
| amazing!
 
  | camtarn wrote:
  | Agreed! It's great to see Quinn turn up on HN. Her channel is
  | an excellent source of very relaxing machining content.
 
| [deleted]
 
| Elof wrote:
| Got the HN hug -
| https://web.archive.org/web/20210619021024/https://blondihac...
 
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2022-02-01 23:00 UTC)