| Title: Explaining modern server monitoring stacks for self-hosting
Author: Solène
Date: 11 September 2022
Tags: nixos monitoring efficiency nocloud
Description: In this article, I'm exploring four different servers
monitoring setups involving Grafana, VictoriaMetrics, Prometheus and
Collectd.
#!/bin/introduction
Hello 👋🏻, it's been a long time I didn't have to take a look at
monitoring servers. I've set up a Grafana server six years ago, and I
was using Munin for my personal servers.
However, I recently moved my server to a small virtual machine which
has CPU and memory constraints (1 core / 1 GB of memory), and Munin
didn't work very well. I was curious to learn if the Grafana stack
changed since the last time I used it, and YES.
There is that project named Prometheus which is used absolutely
everywhere, it was time for me to learn about it. And as I like to go
against the flow, I tried various changes to the industry standard
stack by using VictoriaMetrics.
In this article, I'm using NixOS configuration for the examples,
however it should be obvious enough that you can still understand the
parts if you don't know anything about NixOS.
# The components
VictoriaMetrics is a Prometheus drop-in replacement that is a lot more
efficient (faster and use less resources), which also provides various
API such as Graphite or InfluxDB. It's the component storing data. It
comes with various programs like VictoriaMetrics agent to replace
various parts of Prometheus.
Update: a dear reader shown me VictoriaMetrics can be used to scrape
remote agents without the VictoriaMetrics agent, this reduce the memory
usage and configuration required.
|
| VictoriaMetrics official website |
| VictoriaMetrics documentation "how to scrape prometheus exporters such as node exporter" |
|
Prometheus is a time series database, which also provide a collecting
agent named Node Exporter. It's also able to pull (scrape) data from
remote services offering a Prometheus API. |
| Prometheus official website |
| Node Exporter GitHub page |
|
NixOS is an operating system built with the Nix package manager, it has
a declarative approach that requires to reconfigure the system when you
need to make a change. |
| NixOS official website |
|
Collectd is a agent gathering metrics from the system and sending it to
a remote compatible database. |
| Collectd official website |
|
Grafana is a powerful Web interface pulling data from time series
databases to render them under useful charts for analysis. |
| Grafana official website |
| Node exporter full Grafana dashboard |
|
# Setup 1: Prometheus server scraping remote node_exporter
In this setup, a Prometheus server is running on a server along with
Grafana, and connects to remote servers running node_exporter to gather
data.
Running it on my server, Grafana takes 67 MB, the local node_exporter
12.5 MB and Prometheus 63 MB.
```
USER PID %CPU %MEM VSZ RSS TTY STAT START TIME COMMAND
grafana 837975 0.1 6.7 1384152 67836 ? Ssl 01:19 1:07 grafana-server
node-ex+ 953784 0.0 1.2 941292 12512 ? Ssl 16:24 0:01 node_exporter
prometh+ 983975 0.3 6.3 1226012 63284 ? Ssl 17:07 0:00 prometheus
```
|
| 
|
|
* model: pull, Prometheus is connecting to all servers
## Pros
* it's the industry standard
* can use the "node exporter full" Grafana dashboard
## Cons
* uses memory
* you need to be able to reach all the remote nodes
## Server
```
{
services.grafana.enable = true;
services.prometheus.exporters.node.enable = true;
services.prometheus = {
enable = true;
scrapeConfigs = [
{
job_name = "kikimora";
static_configs = [
{targets = ["10.43.43.2:9100"];}
];
}
{
job_name = "interbus";
static_configs = [
{targets = ["127.0.0.1:9100"];}
];
}
];
};
}
```
## Client
```
{
networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts = [9100];
services.prometheus.exporters.node.enable = true;
}
```
# Setup 2: VictoriaMetrics + node-exporter in pull model
In this setup, a VictoriaMetrics server is running on a server along
with Grafana. A VictoriaMetrics agent is running locally to gather
data from remote servers running node_exporter.
Running it on my server, Grafana takes 67 MB, the local node_exporter
12.5 MB, VictoriaMetrics 30 MB and its agent 13.8 MB.
```
USER PID %CPU %MEM VSZ RSS TTY STAT START TIME COMMAND
grafana 837975 0.1 6.7 1384152 67836 ? Ssl 01:19 1:07 grafana-server
node-ex+ 953784 0.0 1.2 941292 12512 ? Ssl 16:24 0:01 node_exporter
victori+ 986126 0.1 3.0 1287016 30052 ? Ssl 18:00 0:03 victoria-metric
root 987944 0.0 1.3 1086276 13856 ? Sl 18:30 0:00 vmagent
```
|
| 
|
|
* model: pull, VictoriaMetrics agent is connecting to all servers
## Pros
* can use the "node exporter full" Grafana dashboard
* lightweight and more performant than Prometheus
## Cons
* you need to be able to reach all the remote nodes
## Server
```
let
configure_prom = builtins.toFile "prometheus.yml" ''
scrape_configs:
- job_name: 'kikimora'
stream_parse: true
static_configs:
- targets:
- 10.43.43.1:9100
- job_name: 'interbus'
stream_parse: true
static_configs:
- targets:
- 127.0.0.1:9100
'';
in {
services.victoriametrics.enable = true;
services.grafana.enable = true;
systemd.services.export-to-prometheus = {
path = with pkgs; [victoriametrics];
enable = true;
after = ["network-online.target"];
wantedBy = ["multi-user.target"];
script = "vmagent -promscrape.config=${configure_prom} -remoteWrite.url=http://127.0.0.1:8428/api/v1/write";
};
}
```
## Client
```
{
networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts = [9100];
services.prometheus.exporters.node.enable = true;
}
```
# Setup 3: VictoriaMetrics + node-exporter in push model
In this setup, a VictoriaMetrics server is running on a server along
with Grafana, on each server node_exporter and VictoriaMetrics agent
are running to export data to the central VictoriaMetrics server.
Running it on my server, Grafana takes 67 MB, the local node_exporter
12.5 MB, VictoriaMetrics 30 MB and its agent 13.8 MB, which is exactly
the same as the setup 2, except the VictoriaMetrics agent is running on
all remote servers.
```
USER PID %CPU %MEM VSZ RSS TTY STAT START TIME COMMAND
grafana 837975 0.1 6.7 1384152 67836 ? Ssl 01:19 1:07 grafana-server
node-ex+ 953784 0.0 1.2 941292 12512 ? Ssl 16:24 0:01 node_exporter
victori+ 986126 0.1 3.0 1287016 30052 ? Ssl 18:00 0:03 victoria-metric
root 987944 0.0 1.3 1086276 13856 ? Sl 18:30 0:00 vmagent
```
|
| 
|
|
* model: push, each agent is connecting to the VictoriaMetrics server
## Pros
* can use the "node exporter full" Grafana dashboard
* memory efficient
* can bypass firewalls easily
## Cons
* you need to be able to reach all the remote nodes
* more maintenance as you have one extra agent on each remote
* may be bad for security, you need to allow remote servers to write to
your VictoriaMetrics server
## Server
{
networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts = [8428];
services.victoriametrics.enable = true;
services.grafana.enable = true;
services.prometheus.exporters.node.enable = true;
}
```
## Client
```
let
configure_prom = builtins.toFile "prometheus.yml" ''
scrape_configs:
- job_name: '${config.networking.hostName}'
stream_parse: true
static_configs:
- targets:
- 127.0.0.1:9100
'';
in {
services.prometheus.exporters.node.enable = true;
systemd.services.export-to-prometheus = {
path = with pkgs; [victoriametrics];
enable = true;
after = ["network-online.target"];
wantedBy = ["multi-user.target"];
script = "vmagent -promscrape.config=${configure_prom} -remoteWrite.url=http://victoria-server.domain:8428/api/v1/write";
};
}
```
# Setup 4: VictoriaMetrics + Collectd
In this setup, a VictoriaMetrics server is running on a server along
with Grafana, servers are running Collectd sending data to
VictoriaMetrics graphite API.
Running it on my server, Grafana takes 67 MB, VictoriaMetrics 30 MB
and Collectd 172 kB (yes).
```
USER PID %CPU %MEM VSZ RSS TTY STAT START TIME COMMAND
grafana 837975 0.1 6.7 1384152 67836 ? Ssl 01:19 1:07 grafana-server
victori+ 986126 0.1 3.0 1287016 30052 ? Ssl 18:00 0:03 victoria-metric
collectd 844275 0.0 0.0 610432 172 ? Ssl 02:07 0:00 collectd
```
|
| 
|
|
* model: push, VictoriaMetrics receives data from the Collectd servers
## Pros
* super memory efficient
* can bypass firewalls easily
## Cons
* you can't use the "node exporter full" Grafana dashboard
* may be bad for security, you need to allow remote servers to write to
your VictoriaMetrics server
* you need to configure Collectd for each host
## Server
The server requires VictoriaMetrics to run exposing its graphite API on
ports 2003.
Note that in Grafana, you will have to escape "-" characters using "\-"
in the queries. I also didn't find a way to automatically discover
hosts in the data to use variables in the dashboard.
UPDATE: Using write_tsdb exporter in collectd, and exposing a TSDB API
with VictoriaMetrics, you can set a label to each host, and then use
the query "label_values(status)" in Grafana to automatic discover
hosts.
```
{
networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts = [2003];
services.victoriametrics = {
enable = true;
extraOptions = [
"-graphiteListenAddr=:2003"
];
};
services.grafana.enable = true;
}
```
## Client
We only need to enable Collectd on the client:
```
{
services.collectd = {
enable = true;
autoLoadPlugin = true;
extraConfig = ''
Interval 30
'';
plugins = {
"write_graphite" = ''
Host "victoria-server.fqdn"
Port "2003"
Protocol "tcp"
LogSendErrors true
Prefix "collectd_"
'';
cpu = ''
ReportByCpu false
'';
memory = "";
df = ''
Mountpoint "/"
Mountpoint "/nix/store"
Mountpoint "/home"
ValuesPercentage True
ValuesAbsolute False
'';
load = "";
uptime = "";
swap = ''
ReportBytes false
ReportIO false
ValuesPercentage true
'';
interface = ''
ReportInactive false
'';
};
};
}
```
# Trivia
The first section named #!/bin/introduction" is on purpose and not a
mistake. It felt super fun when I started writing the article, and
wanted to keep it that way.
The Collectd setup is the most minimalistic while still powerful, but
it requires lot of work to make the dashboards and configure the
plugins correctly.
The setup I like best is the setup 2. |